Impact of Constitutionalization on the Legal Culture, National Norms, and International Relations in Kazakhstan




constitutionalization, legal system, international law, national law, judicial interpretation


Objective: The relevance of the studied issue lies in that the concept of constitutionalization is increasingly utilized in legal terminology and the spheres of state and international law. However, researchers have not yet developed a unified approach to the concept, as each scholar proposes examining constitutionalization in the context of its impact on specific aspects of legal reality. The study thus aims to explore the effect of constitutionalization not only on the system of national law but also on the national legal system in the broad sense.


Methods: The research goal is achieved through an analysis of scientific literature, legal sources, and legislative documents. Comparative legal and system structural methods are used to understand the relationship between academic theories and the practical application of constitutionalization.


Results: The analysis shows that constitutionalization is a multifaceted process that assumes the integration of constitutional norms and principles into various aspects of legal systems. The study emphasizes the influence of constitutionalization on national legal systems, including such aspects as legal culture, judicial interpretation, and the conformity of legislation with constitutional values.


Conclusion: The concept of constitutionalization is concluded to play a decisive part in the development of modern legal science. The study stresses the importance of regulating legal norms in line with constitutional principles, both nationally and internationally, to ensure effective legal regulation.


Bhatia, A. (2020). Analysis of the administration of rule of law in the present world. Legal Readings.

Blajer, A. (2013). Main legal systems of the world. Renan Consulting.

Bondar, N. S., & Dzhagarian, A. A. (2018). Pravosudie: Orientatsiia na Konstitutsiiu [Justice: Focus on the Constitution]. Moscow: NORMA: INFRA-M.

Bongiovanni, G. (2014). Global constitutionalism and legal theory: A preliminary analysis. Portal de Revistas, 1(2), 170-192.

Brown, G. (2012). The constitutionalization of what? Global Constitutionalism, 1(2), 201-228.

Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2023). Normative Resolution of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated April 21, 2023 No. 10 "On consideration of the conformity to the Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan of paragraph 4 of Article 44, paragraph 3 of Article 44-1 of the Constitutional Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 25, 2000 "On the judicial system and status of judges of the Republic of Kazakhstan" and paragraph 1 of Article 24 of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 4, 2015 "On the Supreme Judicial Council of the Republic of Kazakhstan".

Da Silva, M. (2020). International "constitutions" and comparative constitutional law. Notre Dame Journal of International & Comparative Law, 10(2), 139-172.

Dörr, O. (2015). A European constitutional order? In Proceedings of the Conference: "States and Borders", University of Kobe, Japan.

Drobot, S. E. (2021). Printsip razdeleniia i vzaimodeistviia vlastei v sisteme rossiiskogo konstitutsionalizma [The principle of separation and interaction of powers in the system of Russian constitutionalism]: Dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Legal Sciences. South Ural State University (National Research University), Novosibirsk, 259 p.

Gabrielian, G. E., & Karamalyan, E. V (2020). Ustav OON: Ego rol i mezhdunarodnoe znachenie [The UN Charter: Its role and international significance]. Nauchnyi Vestnik Kryma, 5(28), 1-8.

Guzeeva, O. S. (2020). Constitutionalization of criminal law as a process. Economic Problems and Legal Practice, 4, 219-225.

Khasenov, M. Kh. (2020). Konstitutsionnaia zakonnost i verkhovenstvo prava [Constitutional legality and the rule of law]. In Proceedings of the International scientific and practical conference "Tsennost cheloveka v Evraziiskoi modeli konstitutsionalizma: Ot idei k realnosti (k 25-letiiu Konstitutsii Respubliki Kazakhstan)” (PP. 60-71). Nur-Sultan: KAZGUU University named after. M.S. Narikbaev.

Konshakov, V. M. (2014). Problemy konstitutsionalizatsii pravovogo regulirovaniia sotsialno-trudovykh otnoshenii [Problems of legal regulation of social labor relations]: Dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Legal Sciences. St. Petersburg State University, St. Petersburg, 209 p.

Kravets, I. A. (2002). Formirovanie rossiiskogo konstitutsionalizma [Formation of Russian constitutionalism]: Dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Legal Sciences. Ural State Law Academy, Ekaterinburg, 196 p.

Kruss, V. I. (2018a). Konstitutsionalizatsiia fiskalno-ekonomicheskikh obiazannostei v Rossiiskoi Federatsii [Constitutionalization of fiscal and economic responsibilities in the Russian Federation]. Moscow: NORMA: INFRA-M.

Kruss, V. I. (2018b). Konstitutsionalizatsiia prava: Osnovy teorii [Constitutionalization of law: Fundamentals of theory]. Moscow: NORMA: INFRA-M.

Loughlin, M. (2010). What is constitutionalisation? In P. Dobner, & M. Loughlin (Eds.), The twilight of constitutionalism? (pp. 47-70). Oxford: Oxford Academic.

Mayer, D., Warner, D., Siedel, G. J. & Lieberman, J. K. (2012). Sources of law and their priority. In Law for entrepreneurs (pp. 20-29). Saylor Foundation.

Nursaliyeva, G., Baikenzhina, K., Kalmaganbetova, D., Balgimbekova, G., Seitzhanova, N., & Kussainova, L. (2023). Methodology for the Legislative Application of Evaluative Categories in Criminal Law. Journal of Law and Sustainable Development, 11(5), e725.

Parliament of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (1995). Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Adopted at the Republican referendum on August 30, 1995.

Peters, A. (2013). Pravovye sistemy i protsess konstitutsionalizatsii: Novoe opredelenie sootnosheniia [Legal systems and the constitutionalization process: Redefining the relationship]. Daidzhest Publichnogo Prava [Digest für Öffentliches Recht], 2(2), 239-332.

Plotnikova, I. N. (2021). "Konstitutsionalizatsiia": K voprosu o poniatii ["Constitutionalization”: About the concept]. Izvestiya of Saratov University. Economics. Management. Law, 21(2): 188-197.

Pokol, B. (2002). Constitutionalization and the political fighting through litigation. Jogelméleti Szemle [Journal of Legal Theory], 1, 1-22.

Rainer, A. (2020). Rule of law in the development of constitutional law.

Riedel, J. (2020), Judicial review of judicial appointments in Germany. International Journal for Court Administration, 11(1), 2.

Romano, S. (1975). Die Rechtsordnung. Berlin: Dunker&Humblod, 177 p.

Sapargaliev, G. (2021). Konstitutsionnoe pravo Respubliki Kazakhstan. Akademicheskii kurs [Constitutional law of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Academic course]. Nur-Sultan: Zheti jargy.

Suma, T. A. (2021). The constitution and constitutionalism: A comparative approach.

Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2022). Normative Resolution of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On introducing amendments and additions to some regulatory resolutions of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan on criminal and criminal procedure legislation".

Zharbolova, A. Zh. (2015). K voprosu ob osushchestvlenii narodom zakonotvorcheskoi deiatelnosti v RK [On the exercise of lawmaking activities by the people in the Republic of Kazakhstan]. Bulletin of NAS RK. Series: Social Sciences and Humanities, 5(303), 9-13.




How to Cite

Rakhmetulin, A., Abdrasulov, Y., & Abdrasulova, A. (2023). Impact of Constitutionalization on the Legal Culture, National Norms, and International Relations in Kazakhstan. Journal of Law and Sustainable Development, 11(11), e1329.